Manual Scavenging – Violation of Article 12

Manual Scavenging – Violation of article 21

The following blog will enlighten the audience about the Manual scavenging and its violation with respect to article 21.

What is manual Scavenging?

Manual scavenging in layman’s language is the course of expulsion of human waste from public roads, public potholes, and dry restrooms, and cleaning and disinfection of septic tanks, drains and sewers occasionally. The word Manual obviously connotes the physically cleaning, and conveying, discarding or in any case taking care of, human excreta in an insanitary toilet or in an open channel or sewer or in a septic tank or a pit. The apparatuses normally utilized in this cycle are hand devices, like containers, brushes and digging tools. The laborers need to move the excreta, utilizing brushes and tin plates, put it into bins, which they convey to expendable areas now and again a few kilometers away.

The act of manual scavenging and utilizing human work for cleaning sewers and septic tanks can be regularly seen and is pervasive in Bangladesh and Pakistan. These sterilization laborers, called manual scroungers seldom have any professional stability or any private defensive gear. The work is frequently viewed as dehumanizing Practice, in light of the fact that obviously nobody would believe should do such sort of work without having any private defensive gear.

Curiously the control of disinfections work is characteristically pinked with station in India, clearly in light of the fact that a wide range of cleaning are viewed as modest and are relegated to the gathering from the most reduced standing and rung of social progressive system. In such a standing based society, Dalits are the ones who function as disinfection laborers – as manual foragers, cleaners of channels, as a trash specialists and sweepers of streets. It was assessed that in 2019 that between 40 to 60 percent of the 6 million families of Dalit sub positions are taken part in disinfection work. The most well-known Dalit position performing disinfection work is the Valmiki ( additionally balmiki ) rank.

There was regulation stretched out and explained to remember boycott for utilization of human work for direct cleaning of sewers, trenches, pits and septic tanks in 2013. The development of dry latrines and work of manual foragers to clean such dry latrines was denied. Regardless of the regulations, manual rummaging is as yet drilled in a portion of the states including, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan in 2014. Administration of information even shows that in the period 1993-2021, 971 individuals passed on during the cleaning of the sewers and the septic tanks.

One thing to be called attention to in the point is this that, the term ‘Manual Scavenging’ is not quite the same as the independent term ‘rummaging’, which is perhaps of the most established financial action and alludes to the demonstration of arranging however and picking from disposed of waste. Foragers are individuals who normally gather the garbage from roads, dumpsites, or landfills. Every one of the re-usable things and the recyclable things that can be incorporated into the economy’s creation cycle are gathered y the foragers. This training is more secure and is accounted for to exist in urban communities and towns across the worldwide south.

In 2021, The Public Basic liberties (NHRC) of India maintained for the term to consolidate various types of perilous cleaning. There is a very clear direction division of various kinds of work that is called manual looking through in India. The cleaning of dry lavatories and passing the misfortune on to point of expulsion is generally wrapped up by women, while men are related with cleaning of septic tanks and sewers.


The act of manual scavenging in India traces all the way back to old times. As indicated by the items in consecrated sacred texts and other writing, rummaging by a few explicit ranks of India has existed starting from the start of development. One of the fifteen obligations of slaves counted in Naradiya Samhita was of manual rummaging. This goes on during the Buddhist and Maurya period too.

Manual looking is by and large associated with the position system in India. cleaning of lavatories, yet an extensive variety of cleaning position are viewed as unassuming in India. The elites given out the most humble and polluting position for people from the Dalit people group. The station-based errand of cleaning position can be followed back to the rising of Hinduism and recuperation of the Brahmanical demand during the Gupta time period, thought about the splendid period all through the whole presence of the Indian sub-mainland. The workers regularly had a spot with the Balmiki (or Valmiki) or Hela (or Mehtar) subcastes; considered at the lower part of the ever-evolving framework inside the Dalit social class itself.


  • Despite the passage of two guidelines, the regularity of manual looking is a loosely held bit of information. According to the Financial Rank Statistics 2011, 180,657 families inside India are partaken in manual scrounging for a job. The 2011 Insights of India found 794,000 cases of manual scrounging across India. The domain of Maharashtra, with 63,713, tops the overview with the greatest number of families filling in as manual scroungers, followed by the regions of Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Tripura, and Karnataka. Manual scrounging/searching really makes do in bits of India without authentic sewage structures or safe waste slop the board rehearses. It is accepted to be prevalent in Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, and Rajasthan.
  • In Walk 2014, the High Court of India declared that there were 96 lakh (9.6 million) dry latrines being actually cleansed at this point the particular number of manual scroungers is addressed – official figures put it at under 700,000.
  • Not a wide range of dry lavatories incorporate “manual searching” to debilitate them, yet those that require unsafe treatment of unrefined excreta. If on the other hand the excreta is currently treated or pre-treated in the dry lavatory itself, very much like the case for preparing the dirt restrooms, and pee diverting dry toilets for example, then, at that point, depleting these sorts of restrooms isn’t assigned “manual rummaging”. Holder based sterilization is another structure that doesn’t require manual looking to work notwithstanding the way that it incorporates the releasing of excreta from compartments.
  • The exhausting pits of twin pit latrines isn’t named manual searching in India, as though utilized and discharged properly, the excreta is now treated.
  • The Worldwide Work Association depicts three types of manual rummaging in India-
  • – Expulsion of human fertilizer from public roads and “dry restrooms” (meaning straight forward pit latrines without a water seal, however not dry latrines overall)
  • – Cleaning septic tanks
  • – Cleaning drains and sewers
  • Manual cleaning of rail line lines of excreta dropped from latrines of trains is one more type of manual searching in India.


In India, women who practice manual looking through face strain from their different organizations in case they miss a day since toilets are cleaned reliably. Various women should pick the choice to go up to clean the restrooms. The practical essential that they don’t miss a day holds them back from pursuing substitute occupations like plant work. Also, on the off chance that they can find the means and sponsorship to stop manual looking, women really face crazy strain from the local area.

As well as all that expressed over, the court has expressed a ton of acts connected with the disallowance of manual searching and development of dry restroom. Preclusion of work as manual scroungers to their restoration. The acts are stated as follows –

  • The Employment of Manual Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines (Prohibition) Act, 1993

After six states passed goals mentioning the Central Government to approach a regulation, The Employment of Manual Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines (Prohibition) Act, 1993″, drafted by the Service of Metropolitan Improvement under the Narasimha Rao government, was passed by Parliament in 1993. The demonstration rebuffs the work of scroungers or the development of dry (non-flush) restrooms with detainment for as long as one year or potentially a fine of Rs 2,000. No convictions were acquired under the law during the 20 years it was in force.


Article 12 to 35 contained in Part III of the Indian constitution deals with fundamental Rights. These rights are termed as – Right to equality, Including equality before law, Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of Religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth, and equality of opportunity in matters of employment.

Article 12 in the constitution of India defines what ‘state’ is. Further, Article 13 of the constitution of India specifies which acts of the state should be regulated around by the constitution so that state does not abuse the powers given to it by the constitution.


India banned the practice under the prohibition of employment as manual scavengers and their rehabilitation act, 2013 (PEMSR). This act bans the use of any individual for manually, cleaning, carrying, disposing of or otherwise handling in any manner, human excreta till its disposed.

Any person or agency who engages in any type of activity related to manual scavenging in violation of the provisions of the MS Act, 2013 is punishable under section 8 of the above act, with imprisonment up to 2 years or fine up to rupees 1 lakh or both.


The constitution of India gives us the not insignificant rundown of the relative multitude of central privileges which are accessible to every one of the residents of our country independent of their position, variety orientation, sex, spot of birth and so forth. The main point of having a statement of key right is that sure rudimentary privileges, for example, right to freedom, right to discourse, opportunity of confidence, insurance of life, etc, ought to be viewed as unalienable under all circumstances, it implies that this multitude of regulations, regardless of what the condition is ought to be complied and drilled by every one of the residents as these are the fundamentals. The Right to Security of life and individual freedom and conceived in article

The right to correspondence and the right against abuse are disregarded by the act of the manual searching. This training is an encroachment of the article, of the Indian constitution and a culpable offense. This cruel act of manual rummaging which was even thought to be as humble task to take care of and was for the most part finished by the lower standings of India was restricted in the country 29 years back in 1993 through passing a regulation in such manner by the parliament of India.

As per the association civil rights and the strengthening service, the public authority has station related information on 43,797 individuals participated in manual searching, with more than 42,000 having a place with the booked ranks.

Before Maneka Gandhi’s Choice, the article 21 held an alternate position. The right to life and individual Freedom was ensured exclusively against the erratic activity of the leader and not from regulative. After a ton of deliberation and condemning, article 21 shields all residents from the leader activity as well as from the regulative activity.

Since article 21 is expressed as the article which gives every one of the fundamental freedoms, it has an extremely wide skyline and degree and hence covers every one of the privileges too. The Right to love with human nobility is quite possibly of the most significant and fundamental right which is incorporated and encapsulated under article 21. This article not just aids individuals of the country from the leader activity yet in addition from the regulative activity.

This right was given to individuals so they can carry on with their lives with fundamental human pride, which no one else can grab from them thus the training manual searching was nullified quite a while in the past in the year 1995 by the security of Common Right Demonstration to guarantee the three ought to be no double-dealing of individuals working, particularly to the ones who had a place from planned stations and the booked clans, including the wide range of various lower projects and they ought not be denied of the their privileges and advantages and consequently pronounced a culpable offense in the year 1993.The further given Acts and laws were passed by the legislature to prevent Manual Scavenging –

  • The Employment of Manual Scavenging and Construction of Dry Latrines Prohibition Act, 1993 was passed to prohibit manual scavenging and to ensure that the people who are indulged in this practice are not deprived of their right to live with human dignity. As it is evident from the name of the Act, it prohibits the employment of the manual scavengers and also the building of the insanitary latrines. The violation of the same is punishable with simple imprisonment up to one year or a fine of Rs 2000/- or with both in some cases. This Act and the provisions were made to protect the interest of the workmen involved in this practice but due to the bad implementation and ignorance there were no convictions and this practice kept on going and is still prevalent even after passing of this Act.

2.) The Self Employment Scheme for Rehabilitation of Manual Scavenging, 2007 (SRMS) was passed to help and give help to the manual scroungers and their relatives for their recovery in a few elective occupations.

3.)  The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013. The absolute initial step which was set somewhere near this Act was to ‘obliterate every one of the insanitary restrooms.’ The neighborhood specialists like metropolitan enterprises, rail line specialists and so on will be considered dependable under this Represent the structure and the support of the local area clean lavatories, and should guarantee that they are utilitarian and sterile. The subsequent step was to preclude work of any individual for manual rummaging or dangerous cleaning of sewers and septic tanks.

4.) Further the Demonstration ordered the change of insanitary lavatories into the clean and sterile restrooms in 6 months or less. Likewise, the specialists referenced under this Act need to construct adequate local area clean restrooms as it is viewed as important particularly in the region where the insanitary lavatories have been found. These were the sure goals of passing this Demonstration.

5.) The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation (Amendment) Bill, 2020. This Bill was presented in the Indian Parliament by the Association Government. The principal goals of acquainting this Bill are with kill manual scroungers all around the country from this disgraceful practice and furthermore to take out that multitude of workers who are as of now associated with this debasing position. The Public authority will likewise restore them and their relatives. This Bill sets out a legitimate and a total component to clear the septic tanks and sewers without including the physical work. This Act will guarantee that no human is associated with such practice and legitimate clean local area sterile restrooms will be assembled.


Indeed, even in the wake of passing of these Demonstrations, this debasing practice isn’t canceled. It is the aggregate liability of our administration and of the general public wherein we dwell. It is the obligation of the leader to carry out the regulations passed by the council really and furthermore the obligation of the general public to keep these regulations. As a capable resident of this nation when one sees any individual utilized or enjoyed a manual rummaging or constructing an insanitary lavatory then one must straightforwardly go to the close by police headquarters and report something very similar. Manual Rummaging is an unlawful practice and furthermore an offense. It is the infringement of Article 21. The Constitution of India boycotts the act of distance. Assuming the general public effectively partakes in the issue of destroying manual scroungers from our general public and makes a move against this training any place they see it happening then together we will doubtlessly kill this hazard which has been practically speaking since numerous years.

Author: Mananjot Singh,
Lovely Professional University,Phagwara / BA LLB

Leave a Comment